Good Citizenship: A Series - Part 2

Good Person, Good Worker, Good Citizen

By Lynn Barendsen 

At The Good Project, our primary focus over the past two and a half decades has been on understanding the nature of “work,” identifying the features of good work across the  professions, and developing frameworks, tools, and resources to help nurture good workers and good work.

However, we have not been concerned solely with the individual in the workplace. Although “work” has been our research focus, we recognize that individuals are not only workers. We all play other roles outside of work environments; such roles often require responsibilities to our families and friends, to our neighbors, to society, and to the wider world. In addition to being a good worker, what does it mean to be a good person and a good citizen?

To unpack these questions, it’s helpful to think about two concepts: neighborly morality and ethics of roles.

First, what does it mean to be a good person? This is where the concept of neighborly morality is useful. We often describe neighborly morality as the Golden Rule: treating others in the way that you yourself would like to be treated. We notice ‘good people” in the grocery store (offering to help others carry packages), in our neighborhoods (shoveling walks for elderly neighbors), or on the road (waving others into lines of waiting traffic). Good people think the consequences of their actions upon other—especially those whom they encounter in daily life. 

A good worker is judged on work performed—and here we can make use of the concept of ethics of roles: the standards by which different professions measure their workers. Is it of high quality in terms of the standards of that particular workplace? Additionally, is the work ethical, taking into account the particular ethical standards of that workplace or profession? To be sure, not all workers are subject to the equivalent of a Hippocratic oath; nonetheless, workers are (or should be!) attuned to the ethical implications of their work or an ethical code which might include “doing no harm” or taking responsibility for one’s efforts. And does the worker find meaning in work? To be clear, a good worker may not feel excellent, ethical, and engaged every single day; but in general, a “good” worker strives to meet each of these criteria to the best of his/her ability.

As we consider good citizenship, it might be argued that neighborly morality and ethics of roles both come into play. Think “good person” with a civic lens: good neighbors consider their responsibilities to their neighborhood and treat others as they themselves would like to be treated. These are the elements of neighborly morality.

However, the ethics of the role of citizen are also relevant, involving knowing the expectations of a citizen in one’s community, region, or nation. In the US, for example, do individuals vote, and when they do so, are they well informed about candidates and questions on the ballot? Do they consider their responsibilities as citizens and recognize the impact of their civic actions (or lack thereof)? And finally, are they engaged—paying attention, educating themselves about current issues, and taking action, as appropriate? Of course, the meaning, rules and values of citizenship may vary from place to place. Nonetheless, the 3 Es constitute a useful starting point for considering how individuals understand their civic duties.

Recently, there has been a resurgence of attention to civics education—overdue, in my opinion, and vitally important. At The Good Project, we embrace an approach that guides not only the citizen, but also the person and the worker, by encouraging responsibility in all the spheres of our lives. We advocate a sense of neighborly morality, acknowledging that our “neighbors” are now global as well as local.

 The rules governing many spheres of work are also changing—new roles are being created (for example, in the digital realm), and old ones are disappearing (in many white collar positions). Alas, we can’t always rely only on overly politicized educational systems to offer guidance about standards for good work. Across many communities and institutions, including in educational systems, responsible adults need to model appropriate behaviors and attitudes. Only in that way can we hope to have members of the emerging generation accept their responsibilities in all they do, as persons, as workers, and as citizens.

Good Citizenship: A Series - Part 1

An Introduction: What is “Good Citizenship”?

By The Good Project Team

 The problems facing the world today are ample and, in a globalized and interconnected planet, are more likely to affect all nations and all persons. The international community recently witnessed the degree to which a previously unknown pathogen, COVID-19, could within weeks disrupt daily life for billions of people. Climate change poses an urgent threat for the survival of human beings as well as the numerous species with which we share the earth. Social disparities along racial and ethnic lines persist and are in some cases widening.

It is imperative for people (especially those with the time and resources to do so) to address these issues and to do so collaboratively. When we consider people coming together in pursuit of a goal that will benefit the common good, the terms “civic” and “citizenship” often come to mind.

How do those of us on The Good Project define “good citizenship”? What are the ways of thinking that will encourage citizens to contribute to a better world?

Launched in the middle 1990s, The Good Project initially investigated how individuals were carrying out their work under conditions of rapid technological change and strong market forces, which have only accelerated in the succeeding quarter century. Our research team conducted in-depth interviews about work with individuals drawn from a a range of domains—including law, medicine, journalism, and education. We asked our informants to consider their formative influences, beliefs, values, supports, obstacles, responsibilities, ethical standards, and allied issues. As a result of this extensive research, our “good work” framework emerged. As we now conceptualize it, good work is characterized by“3 Es”: it is high quality (Excellent), concerned with consequences (Ethical), and meaningful (Engaging).

The bulk of our research has focused on people’s professional lives. But the role of worker is obviously not the only role that individuals occupy in their multifaceted lives—nor is work the only sphere in which we interact with and influence others. One may, for example, think of oneself as a “mom,” a “daughter,” and a “friend,” and act differently depending on which role is dominant in a particular moment.

“Citizen” is yet another lens through which we might view ourselves. And so we have recently pondered: Can we conceptualize “citizenship” in ways that will encourage people to do “good” for the benefit of all?

What is a “good citizen”?

First and foremost, when referring to citizenship, we do not simply mean legal citizenship in a particular nation or country. Instead, in our formulation, a citizen is an inhabitant of a place or community, whether or not that comes with legal recognition. Although it is undoubtedly more difficult without legal citizenship, we believe everyone has a right and a responsibility to participate in civic life.

Accordingly, at The Good Project, we extend our conception of the 3Es of ethics, excellence, and engagement to describe and evaluate the meaning of “good citizenship.” With that schema in mind, good citizens are individuals who strive to do the right thing, not principally for their own self interest but for their broader communities and for society (ethics); know the rules, regulations, and norms of their particular communities and contexts, as well as conditions when it is proper or even necessary to defy them (excellence); and take an interest and find meaning in working for the betterment of community and society (engagement). As examples familiar to readers, we think of Cesar Chavez, Dr. Martin Luther King, or Malala Yousafzai; and while most of us cannot presume to accomplish what these heroic figures have accomplished, these exemplary citizens nonetheless serve as inspiration.

This way the 3 Es of good citizenship manifest themselves and resonate with one another will differ depending on one’s values, environmental circumstances, and upbringing. For some individuals, voting regularly may be sufficient political action to qualify as “doing the right thing.” For others, weekly protests calling for large-scale social change might be necessary in order to feel one has done enough. The issues that are salient to particular individuals will also vary.

At The Good Project we have gathered evidence in support of our claim that “good citizens” are ethical, engaged, and excellent. In our analysis, they are also able to critically consider the rings of responsibility; in so doing, their ultimate actions should be beneficial not only to themselves, but also to those in their various communities. It follows, then, that individuals would be acting in accordance with the principles of “good citizenship” if:

  • When encountering dilemmas, individuals took the time to critically think about how they define the various communities and tried to act, or not act, in accordance with what they felt would do the most good for their communities rather primarily than for themselves (ethics).

  • Individuals took the time to know the norms, rules, and/or laws of their various communities (excellence).

  • Individuals displayed an interest in events and issues relevant to their various communities (engagement).

In the accompanying set of blogs, we explore good citizenship and good work through a variety of approaches and perspectives. Featured are:

  • A discussion of the distinctions between a good person, a good worker and a good citizen

  • The application of the Good Work “5 Ds” framework to unpack a dilemma

  • A discussion of how good citizenship can be achieved through good work

  • A consideration of the meaning and the achievement of global citizenship.

GCI Series: Shinn and Good Work

The Global Citizens Initiative hosts an annual Fellowship Summit to cultivate young “global citizens” to become “lifelong leaders of positive change.” In July of 2019, 28 high school students from 15 different countries gathered together for a 10-day experience in Tokyo, Japan. These students are each responsible for the design and development of a service learning project to be carried out over the course of a 10 month period. Their projects are “glocal” – addressing a global problem at a local level. In Tokyo, the students were supported by a group of Teaching Assistants, themselves all alumni of the GCI Fellowship Program. The Good Project has been in consultation with GCI since its formation, and we follow the work of its participants with interest. We recently had the opportunity to catch up with several GCI alums and ask them about their work, their thoughts about Good Work, and reflections about their experiences with GCI.


About Shinn Taniya

Shin.jpg

My name is Shinn Taniya. I am a Japanese citizen, but you will usually find me in Southern California as I attend college there. As a junior, I am majoring in Computer Science, and I also hope to concentrate in Economics and Philosophy. I participated in the Global Citizens Youth Summit during the summer of 2016 and worked on a service project to raise awareness for LGBTQ+ teenagers in Japanese schools. I was also a TA for the summer 2019 session held in Japan. My passions range from music and sports to studying the ethics of technology.

What does it mean to do “good work” today?

To me, good work can be defined in multiple ways. One interpretation is the act of working on values and causes that one is passionate about. Hence, it is a way in which one can fulfill a purpose in life by earning achievements that are representative of their core beliefs.

Another way in which I understand this expression is the act of challenging the status quo. I am not stating that one should take on an anti-establishment persona. Instead, I am pointing out the importance of identifying and protesting against existing socio-political flaws.

Finally, I believe that good work can be interpreted as practicing self-care. Since almost all advocacy groups place the utmost importance on vulnerable communities, they often forget to maintain their personal health and wellness. Therefore, “good work” should not only be defined as bringing about change for others but also should include practicing self-improvement, as no “good work” can be done if the person attempting to achieve it is exhausted and insecure.

Tell us about your understanding of the community. What are the communities of which you feel a part of?

Since I had the privilege of being able to travel around the world, I have been able to immerse myself in a wide variety of communities. Through these experiences, I was able to master Japanese, Chinese, and English, which has enabled me to further comprehend the distinct attributes of each community.

However, this multi-cultural experience also complicated my sense of identity. Due to frequent transitions between significantly different environments, I do not identify with any particular community. Everywhere I go, I feel alienated to a certain extent due to this multicultural identity I have developed. For example, when I am in Japan, I am treated as Japanese-American due to my foreign mannerisms, and when I am in the United States, I am viewed as a Japanese international student. Since having a strong self-identity is essential in building one’s character, I am working hard to establish a deeper understanding of myself. Furthermore, I know that my struggle and circumstances share many similarities with others that embody this notion of a multicultural identity. Therefore, in any community, I try my best to make myself and those around me comfortable by encouraging the establishment of a just community sentiment.

Is there a particular role model who has helped inspire you to do “good work,” either real or fictional? What is it about this role model that has inspired you?

A role model who has inspired me to do “good work” is definitely my father. Although I see how this is a cliche answer, my father is the person who allowed me to explore all avenues of life and understand the moral values which define the person I am today. As an entrepreneur investor, my father has always reminded me that his work philosophy is to motivate himself and others to practice my above-defined notion of “good work”.

Tell us about your work. What projects are you currently involved with? How might what you are doing now relate to the work you began with GCI?

There are many different projects I am currently involved with. First of all, I am taking online courses to fulfill my requirements as a computer science major. This has taken up the majority of my time and has altered my sleep schedule greatly, as my classes go from 1 am-8 am in my time zone. Second, I currently have an internship as a bioinformatics programmer. My role is to extract/analyze genomic information to contribute to continuous improvements in the pharmaceutical industry. Finally, I engage in activism through my involvement with the advocacy group Japan in Solidarity. This student-led organization has the mission of educating the Japanese public about a wide variety of socio-politico-economic challenges. The three central topics for the past couple of months have been BLM, COVID-19, and LGBTQ+ discrimination.

A brief summary of my background includes: multiple internships with Human Rights Watch, a leader of my high school’s Human Rights Coalition, and organizing a project under GCI’s mentorship to tackle discrimination against LGBTQ+ teenagers in Japanese educational institutions. To provide a brief summary of my achievements in each, for Human Rights Watch, I worked as a journalist to write articles and attend conferences pertaining to topics such as: International Justice, North Korean and Syrian Refugees, LGBTQ+, Women’s

and Children’s Rights, Migrant’s Rights. For my high school, my co-leaders and I established a network between our high school and prominent human rights organizations such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty Resources. Finally, for the GCI project, my greatest achievement was working with Human Rights Watch personnel to film a documentary that highlighted the immoral treatment of LGBTQ+ teenagers in the Japanese community. Consequently, I was able to assist and participate in the premiere of the film at the Human Rights Watch Annual Summit in 2016.

It is evident that my current advocacy work aligns with the ethical issues I tackled in the past.

How do you feel your current projects are connected or not to this view of “good work”?

From an ethical perspective, I believe that the work I am doing is definitely connected to my interpretation of “good work.” However, the overwhelming amount of work I have on a daily basis is definitely exhausting and has taken a toll on my health. Furthermore, adding on COVID-19 induced stress definitely does not help my situation. In order to focus on recovering, I have taken a few initiatives. First, I have been spending more time exercising which I believe helps improve my mood significantly. Second, I have been frequenting my close friends’ homes so that I can enjoy non-academic activities without placing myself and others at risk of COVID-19. Third, I picked up new outdoor hobbies such as hiking, biking, and tanning to decrease the time I spend in front of a computer. Finally, I started to turn down requests to complete what I perceive as less meaningful tasks so that I can focus on more significant matters.

How and where do you find meaning in your work?

I have been asked this question many times, but the meaning in my work has always been the ability to personally observe the “good work” I have done on individuals and communities. Nothing is as fruitful as successfully challenging values and conditions that contradict my moral code, as I feel rewarded for my hard work. An archetype of this would be the aforementioned instance where I was able to attend the Human Rights Watch Annual Summit to premiere the documentary I helped to realize. Since I assisted in all aspects, including introducing to the director the protagonist of the film, an elementary school friend of mine who is a victim of extreme bullying that targeted his sexuality, it felt as though the documentary represented the culmination of all of my efforts. I still remember feeling incredibly satisfied after prominent activists walked up to me after the premiere and congratulated our team for shedding light on this complicated issue. Hence, I find meaning in my work by observing the impact it has on individuals and communities.

GCI Series: Ukay and Good Work

The Global Citizens Initiative hosts an annual Fellowship Summit to cultivate young “global citizens” to become “lifelong leaders of positive change.” In July of 2019, 28 high school students from 15 different countries gathered together for a 10-day experience in Tokyo, Japan. These students are each responsible for the design and development of a service learning project to be carried out over the course of a 10 month period. Their projects are “glocal” – addressing a global problem at a local level. In Tokyo, the students were supported by a group of Teaching Assistants, themselves all alumni of the GCI Fellowship Program. The Good Project has been in consultation with GCI since its formation, and we follow the work of its participants with interest. We recently had the opportunity to catch up with several GCI alums and ask them about their work, their thoughts about Good Work, and reflections about their experiences with GCI.


About Onyinyechi Ukaire (Ukay)

Picture1.jpg

Ukay was born in Abuja, Nigeria, where he grew up until age seventeen, when he left for South Africa to complete high school. He then moved on to Tufts University, Medford, United States where he obtained his Bachelor’s in Biochemistry and Computer Science. Since graduating in May 2018, he has been working in Dr. Bruce Walker’s lab as a Bioinformatics Analyst, analyzing and visualizing sequencing data for different types of immune cells. In his free time, Ukay steps outs of his comfort zone to try something new. Recently, he tried making roasted halibut with lemons, olives and rosemary, as advertised in The New York Times. (It turned out about a quarter as good!)

What does it mean to do “good work” today?

I face a dilemma in understanding how to carry out “good work” every day. When deciding how to do good work, I might, for example, choose to help a friend achieve a goal by contributing a quota to their GoFundMe page, and the friend might feel helped; yet doing so each day would also mean that I would deplete limited resources. Of course, such an instance is just one scenario, as quandaries, I now realize, are present in many opportunities to do “good work”: affording routine food to the destitute might inadvertently insult their pride; saying “hello” to elderly neighbors might do little when those greeted expect a welcoming conversation; celebrating others might render “smiles” but can, possibly, do little to clean up pain that facile smiles belie.

Despite being ostensibly inevitable, these dilemmas have humbled me and, ultimately, taught me that to do “good work” is to deliver selfless services, however discomfiting they seem. What I think matters little. What really matters is that those I hope to help actually find my actions helpful. Doing good work, to me, means what I do is of adequate help, as perceived by intended (and hopefully unintended) recipients.

Tell us about your understanding of community. What are the communities of which you feel a part?

This question arouses identity conflicts within me. You learn from a young age that you are this or that, only to be told later — by uncritical societal eyes — that you are something else. For me, a perceived shift in identity started where I grew up in my home country, Nigeria, where I was time after time reminded that I am an Igbo tribesman who grew up in the north (where Igbo men rarely abide). That is, I wasn’t Igbo, at least not enough so, in spite of what my parents had taught me.

Funny enough, perceived shifts in identity continued outside Nigeria. When I moved to South Africa to complete high school, my identity “changed,” only this time I was called Nigerian. And later, in the United States (U.S.) and United Kingdom (U.K.), where I relocated to complete undergraduate studies, I was simply “Black,” if not “African,” or mistakenly “African-American.” Bear in mind these terms conjure notable yet divergent images in mind (Black, in a way, means my happiness could become fleeting when feelings of thrill are juxtaposed with unconscious reminders of unjust, racial discrimination; African confers knowing substantially about an immensely rich continent of which I know little), which made me feel like some super morphing organism whose identity is anything but fixed.

Interestingly, that notion made me impute some degree of naivety on those who were eager to trade one label for another. I am perceived as Igbo, Nigerian, African, or Black — and the list is likely incomplete. Whatever my observed identities from the point of view of another, there are landmark characteristics in communities to which I belong: they groomed me in significant ways, without them I’d not be the man I am today, and, fortunately, I call them family, not just community. To those to whom I’m beholden — my family (for affording me nostalgic memories and foundational principles of genuine love, care and comedy for painful issues); my high schools, Federal Government Academy in Nigeria and African Leadership Academy in South Africa; multiple families (for engaging my intellect, pushing me to grow, and challenging me to expect more from others); Tufts in the U.S., Oxford in the U.K., and indeed other institutions across Western Europe; the Global Citizens Initiative (GCI) who, on top of family, is synonymous to true friendship for they not only demand my learning but also invite my teachings; tutors I know in person and authors like Chimamanda Adichie, Chinua Achebe, Dale Carnegie, and Trevor Noah with whom I only interface through their various works; and many, many more — I’m immensely grateful. Once, my communities entailed blood ties and neighbors; now, they’re more numerous, less geographically bounded, and, surprisingly, unbridled in their positive effects on me.

The journey to finding rightful fits within my “communities” wasn’t without errors, yet they afforded unique opportunities to grow. Nigerian, as I’m often labeled, traditionally comes with a sprinkle of sexism, but I’ve grown to know the necessity of lifting women up as equal to men. Where I once subscribed zealously to advancing religious ideas into law, I now advocate for legislation that does not cripple another’s freedom.  

Is there a particular role model who has helped inspire you to do “good work”, either real or fictional? What is it about this role model that has inspired you?

I’ve had so many influences over my life that it’s best I limit my recollection to those significant ties that even a faulty memory cannot suppress. Many models stem from literary readings and group discourses (with faculty and peers) during the African Studies (AS) course at African Leadership Academy and during seminars led by facilitators like Dr. Eimer Page at GCI. I think of people like W.E.B. Du Bois, who took up the mantle to stand up for what he believed was the right thing to do, no matter the discomfiture. I think of people like Wangari Mathai, a Kenyan environmental activist and winner of the Nobel Prize, who consistently engaged with her community in social service. People like Ms. Friedman, my AS educator, who showed me why cynicism is important, what to filter as I read or listen or see, and how to do so. Those sets of people have taught and continually teach me how to serve others. In addition, however, my deepest inspirations to do “good work” predate the aforementioned readings and discussions and are based on spiritual tenets I first began to conceive at churches. It’s mandatory to tithe (Deuteronomy 14:22-23, 1 Corinthians 16:2), or, less dogmatically, you can do good work on your terms (2 Corinthians 9:7). Taken together, the Bible opines giving as God’s work and cardinal to unlocking prosperity for all. Although these biblical teachings talk about tithing and giving, I tend to apply their teaching more broadly and creatively, incorporating acts like offering time, thoughtful remarks, physical help, and whatever snags my attention.

It might seem surprising that my role models are distant. You’d expect that my immediate family or close friends continually inspire me to do “good work,” and in many ways, that view is not incorrect. Yet I find my tribal adage, Ora na-azu nwa — it takes a village to raise a child — to be a more inclusive capture of these influences, rightly described as eclectic. 

Tell us about your work. What projects are you currently involved with? How might what you are doing now relate to the work you began with GCI?

I currently work as a bioinformatics analyst for Dr. Bruce Walker’s lab at Ragon Institute of MGH, MIT, and Harvard. What got me to Ragon? Having lived in South Africa, I was conversant and deeply aware of HIV prevalence in the community; for some women their schooling was interrupted, and their futures hampered by the diagnosis. I was even more troubled when the World Health Organization published a summary which explicates how the African region is disproportionately affected, with 1 in 25 people infected and with two-thirds of worldwide infections (https://www.who.int/gho/hiv/en/). Around the same time, I was learning that health is inextricably linked to economics, as is demonstrated by the current coronavirus pandemic, and to development, since healthy citizens can more actively contribute to society than unhealthy ones. Bear in mind that at the time, I was learning biochemistry and computer science at Tufts University and thought my experiences thus far could somehow contribute to a solution. My interests landed me a spot at Ragon, where I have been contributing towards HIV immunology and vaccine research.

More directly, I support an orphanage at my hometown in Suleja, Nigeria, called God’s Love Trust Orphanage Home (https://aoafoundations.com/aoaf-visits-gods-love-trust-orphanage-home-suleja/). Although the two projects articulated are not directly linked to GCI, they are, in fact, borne out of the humanitarian need to subdue human suffering or enhance pleasures — a conscious effort GCI helped to nourish. I anticipate that the current projects will continue, and new ones will form, and in all, they’ll assist to making lives somewhat easier and happier.

How do you feel your current projects are connected or not to this view of “good work”?

It would be a dream for a therapeutic vaccine for HIV to be completed soon. If that happened, then a large number of downstream problems would be tackled. For instance, infected women will no longer face stigma associated with carrying rattling pills around; normally, people’s behavior debase around women who are considered infected. Likewise, uninfected women will no longer worry about carrying prophylactic pills which can also attract unwanted stigma. As with any speculative effects, the sanguine outlook can be viewed as reaching too far, yet that optimism is needed to pull through in a case as acute as handling HIV infections, particularly in Africa. Whatever the gleaned benefits active help offers, in immune therapies or in raising health awareness, tying those merits to doing “good work” hinges on the appraisal of recipients. Therefore, it is required to understand what those who receive help actually think about the help. Such a metric is better demonstrated with the orphanage I support, as they are wont to give invaluable verbal remarks, sometimes captured by videos.

How and where do you find meaning in your work?

I’ve always been fond of social entrepreneurship and helping my local communities in whatever way I can. In my high school thesis defense, I argued, “Social entrepreneurship is gold, but capital entrepreneurship is the gateway to social entrepreneurship.” Here I was tempering my desire to positively impact my community with the practicality of doing so, especially under situations where resources are circumscribed. Applying the same philosophy to my current work, I knew contributing to health care should be a core focus for many, if not most, social endeavors. (I reasoned that without healthy workers, a lot of benefits like meaningful prosperity and happy living might not ensue.) While health care is important, the more I learned about it, the more I was humbled by the magnitude of the undertaking. So, I decided to focus my efforts on certain types of problems within healthcare.

 What I providently settled for was HIV vaccine research, which in 2018, when I graduated, was one of the most pressing issues in my time. Indeed, it remains so, except now I’m also increasingly thinking about coronavirus vaccines, on which I was able to deliver a presentation in the past week.

Tell us about your biggest challenges, and how you work to tackle them.

Finding like minds who are passionate about solving seemingly intractable problems like creating a vaccine for a rapidly mutating HIV that evades the immune system is exacting, especially from a standpoint of evaluating vaccine designs. People with interests within this field, coupled with skills and fueled by desire to translate scientific solution into imminent, practical human therapies, are quite hard to find. That could help to explain why finding the right collaborations within the field is difficult. Nevertheless, I’ve been able to find a niche at Ragon Institute and, fortuitously, have been able to find similar minds by networking with scientists and students through seminars within and outside the institute.

Have you ever faced a dilemma where you weren’t sure what the “right” course of action was? How did you handle this situation?

Certainly. And too often. One significant moment was when I decided to not pursue medicine as a career: in some ways, I was terrified of the decision, as I didn’t know what exactly would be the “right” decision. I ended up following my gut just to make sure that I sought to do what I thought was right. Another notable instance was my choice of whether or not to actively contribute to educating friends about racial issues. Although those willing to learn should work out the right approach to doing so, it can often feel nettlesome when the topic to be learned is as elusive as racism itself — it is difficult to understand what does not occur naturally and, in some ways, is counter-intuitive. This quandary is best illustrated in what I may safely deem the awakening racial consciousness in the United States. I, alongside many others, have known for a while that white cops lynch black bodies. That there will come a time of reckoning for justice to be demanded comes to us with little surprise. The gruesome murders of George Floyd, an unarmed black man allegedly guilty of employing a phony twenty dollar bill, by kneeling on his neck to choke him for eight minutes and forty-eight seconds, and Breonna Taylor, a black woman asleep in her own home, by shooting her with more bullets than needed to kill her, were the culmination of insidious and decades-long racial discrimination. During the weeks that followed those two deaths, I read a wealth of e-mails and texts aimed at addressing systemic racism and racial issues: my workplace sought help to draft a diversity and inclusion statement, and many acquaintances reached out for the first time in many months, even years, to check on how I was doing, and specifically ask how they could help. Given the circumstance, I misconstrued their inquiry to mean that they offered to help me. Upon clarification, it became clear that what they wanted was to learn how to help. What was particularly exciting to see was that many were receptive to discussing a tricky subject, perhaps heretofore not conversant with police brutality—more than enough mainstream black music artists have a song which broaches the topic, and popular films like The Hate U Give do justice to at once informing and entertaining the sympathetic and the curious. To some, it was their first time ever dealing with such a situation, and they were happy to simply hear from me that joining a peaceful protest was an honest attempt to stand in solidarity. Where I’d have once responded with nothing more than a friendly pointer to other resources, in that moment I found it worthwhile to educate others, even though it felt arduous, risked arousing resentment, or was seemingly futile. Trying felt “right.”

February Round-Up: Top 5 Articles

As usual, February has been a busy month at The Good Project. If you missed it, take a look at our February Newsletter, which offers a wealth of resources for Black History Month, and more. Here, check out a few more resources that caught our attention throughout the month:  (Links in title)

  1. To Serve Better: This project from the Harvard Gazette shares stories of people who are “committed to public purpose and to making a positive difference in communities throughout the country.” You can read about people like Gwen Thompkins, executive producer of the music radio show “Music Inside Out,” sharing the music of Louisiana with the wider world. In reading the stories of these individuals, consider: do these individuals embody the 3 Es of good work?

  2. Being Good in a World of Need: Take a look at this webinar with Rutgers Distinguished Professor of Philosophy Larry Temkin, hosted at Harvard’s Safra Center for Ethics. Dr. Temkin discusses some of his worries regarding global aid efforts and how they might actually bring about worse outcomes in some of the world’s poorest regions. He explains that what is morally right for the individual might be morally wrong for the collective, and vice versa. How might we take the lessons Dr. Temkin describes and apply them to our own efforts to do good work?

  3. Evolution from an ‘I’ to a ‘We’ Culture: In this article on his new book with Shaylyn Romney Garrett, The Upswing, Robert Putman (of Bowling Alone fame) speaks to how American society moved from an an individualistic ‘I’ culture during the early 1900s “Gilded Age” to a more collectivistic ‘we’  culture, only to become more individualistic since the Reagan years, with the 1990s serving as a new “Gilded Age.” Putnam urges a return to a more ‘we’ oriented culture and hopes that movements like Black Lives Matter will help urge Americans in this direction. At The Good Project, we use the Rings of Responsibility to help individuals think about their responsibilities to self, others, community, profession, and wider society. How can this framework help you think about moving from an ‘I’ to a ‘we’ culture in your own life? 

  4. Your Ideas are not Your Identity: Adam Grant’s new book Think Again: The Power of Knowing What You Don’t Know delves into the importance of intellectual humility--being aware of what we don’t know--and how that relates to our ability and willingness to change our opinions and ideas. In this article, Grant speaks to the “value of rethinking” ideas; he argues that rather than argue for a binary (I’m right, you’re wrong), we need to complexify ideas and try to get to the nuance of various arguments. To do this, we need to ask questions and listen to each other’s arguments. If you’re interested in thinking more about arguments and their connection to Good Work, check out our workbook with the Better Arguments Project. We contend that “better arguments lead to good work.” 

  5. Myth of the Lazy Genius: Who do you think of when you think of a genius? Bill Gates? Steve Jobs? As Andrei Cimpian points out in this article for Character Lab, you most likely thought of someone male. At The Good Project, we often talk about the importance of mentors and role models--and certainly, who we look up to helps create our ideas of what it means to do good work. But as Dr. Cimpian points out, it’s important that we don’t unwittingly think only of mentors who “naturally” come by their skills or who we think have innate talent (often male role models), and thereby shun role models who work hard to get where they are in life and persist through challenge after challenge (often female role models). What implicit stereotypes might you hold about role models or mentors in your life? How might these stereotypes affect your views of what it means to do good work?